Surface finishes of the paint, varnish, enamel, and lacquer type comprising a baked coating carrying a synthetic resin



Patented Apia 121, 19 36 SURFACE FINISHES or rim man's- NISH, ENAMEL, AND LACQUER TYPE COM- PRISING A BAKED COATING CARRYING A SYNTHETIC RESIN Carleton Ellis, MontclairyN. 1., assignorto Ellis- Foster Company, a corporation of New Jersey No Drawing.

This invention relates to surface finishes, especially to finishes comprising a baked coating, of utility for various purposes, as will be more fully hereinafter described.

Finishes employing synthetic resins have been described in my pending applications Serial Nos. 684,358 filed Jan. 4, 1924 and 22,882, filed Apr. 13, 1925 and these disclosures constitute the basis of the subject matterof the present invention;

[3) Reference will first be made to Serial 684,358.

In the same manner as set forth in said application the invention will be. considered more particularly with respect to its applications in the automobile industry. The painting. of automobile bodies with a durable coating has long been. a problem. Automobile bodies, being exposed to sun and rain, usually present a dilapidated appearance after a seasons use. A durable surface for exposed body parts is much desired. 20 One object of the present invention is to achieve a high degree of durability for coated metal by the use of relatively cheap and available materlals. 4

'In the exterior finish of an automobile body there is required a certain degree of hardness to resist abrasion, coupled with toughness and elasticity. Furthermore the coating must adhere tenaciously so as not to chip or scale ofiwhen handled roughly. A marked degree of resistance to light and moisture and all weather conditions is important.

Nitrocellulose coatings of themselves often do not adhere well to metal, especially when the coated surface is kept wet for some time. The 35 nitrocellulose film has a tendency to strip and peel.

Serial 684,358 indicates how the tendency noted in the preceding paragraph is minimized by the aid of a synthetic resin, particularly one compat- 40 ible with nitrocellulose. The synthetic resin acts not only as an agent to confergreater adherence, but also increases the total binder solids, thereby giving greater substance and producing a more eifective finish. The surface finish, whether in- 45 tentionally dull or lustrous, should have a qualityof smoothness which results only when sufficient binding agent is present to cement or bind together the particles of pigment.

i There are very definite limits to the solubility 50 of nitrocellulose. The same is true of the natral resins. Furthermore, some, of the natural ums or resins are by no means compatible with nitrocellulose. Only a restricted number of the natural resins are appropriate for compounding 55 with nitrocellulose and the supply of these nat- Application February 3, 1930, Serial No. 425,719

17 Claims. (Cl- 91-. 70) g ural resins is limited or the market prices thereon are subject to considerable fluctuation, which is disadvantageous from a manufacturing stand- 'point. On the other hand, there are a number of synthetic resins which, according to the present invention, may be used without the restrictions or disturbances imposed in using the natural resins, whichis acondition of'afiairs highly, advantageous. Furthermore, the cost of manu-' facture of such synthetic resins, generally speak- .ing, is not subject to great variation due to violent fluctuations in the cost of raw materials The following paragraphs denoted by numerals indicate some of the considerations, conditions and requirements involved in connection with the present invention.

1. Consistency of the coating composition.-' The consistency should be such that the composition can be applied by means-of a brush or a spraying device. If applied by the former method,

. the composition should dry slowly enough to not show brush marks. It should work freely under I the brush. This depends in part on the proportion of solvents and their degree of volatility. A quicker drying medium may be used for application by spraying. v

2. Quick drying.-In any event, the qualityof quick-drying generally .is very important, as this feature allows several coats to be applied in a day. With a quick-drying material articles may be moved through the paint department rapidly and less space therefore is requiredfor the operation.

3. Sand papering.-Th surface desirably should be capable of being sand papered soon after application, without gumming of the sand paper.

4. Avoidance of precipitation-There should be no precipitation during drying due to achange in the proportion of solvent by differences in the rate of evaporation. The solvent employed is usu- 4o ally composite and the components thereof should be selected and adjusted'to prevent any precipitation or coagulation during the drying period.

5. Water elimination-In the preferred form of coating material, water should not be present. 5 This may be secured by care in the selection of the raw materials and especially by the use of anhydrous solvents. If Water is present a high boiling solvent or water-eliminant preferably is" added. This solvent should exertits solvent effact not only on the nitrocellulose, but also on the synthetic resin during the stage of dryingwhen .water is being expelled.

6. vTotal solids.-The coating composition Preferably'sliould have a high content of total solids,

.action of light and moisture.

preferably 50 per cent or more, in order that each application of a coat Will leave on drying a substantial film. Since solvents or thinners represent a loss, as they are used only to render the composition liquid for application, the percentage of solvents or thinners should be kept as low as possible. consistent with ease of application. Expensive solvents usually are not feasible, as the cost of manufacture should be kept low.

7. Pigments-There is a direct connection or co-operative effect existing between pigment and binder. resins suitably incorporated with pigment are more durable and resistant than the unextended film. The pigment should be compatible with nitrocellulose and not be of an acid character such as would tend to impair the stability of the nitrocellulose to an objectionable degree. If stabilizers of a basic character are used in the nitrocellulose, the pigment should not have any action on these. Also the pigment should not produce any thickening or livering effects with the synthetic resin employed. Mineral colors such as ochre, umber, iron oxide or mineral red, various lakes, and the like, may be used. White pigments may be employed for making enamels. It is important to have the pigment finely divided and it is best to grind the pigment either with the solvents or the solution in the solvents of either the nitrocellulose or the synthetic resin, or both.

8. Synthetic resin.-This material must be compatible or blend adequately with nitrocellulose, as the composition dries the resin should colloid well with the nitrocellulose. Furthermore, the resin should be soluble in solvents appropriate for nitrocellulose, including any high boiling solvents used as water eliminants, which solvents are generally last to leave the coating. Even though the solid constituents blend in the original solution, separation may occur as the solvents evaporate, due to changing composition.

This should not occur and the ratio of one solvent to another in evaporation of a composite solvent preferably should be such as will at all times accommodate and promote a colloidal blend of the nitrocellulose and synthetic resin.

If nitrocellulose is incorporated with an in compatible resin. in a suitable solvent mixture, the liquid, especially if very viscous, may dry without segregation. In the solid film which forms the incompatible constituents will, however, be in a state of tension or stress and aggregation, yielding a brittle product. This result comes about on standing, especially under the Such a coating possesses very little durability. Synthetic resins having, like camphor, a slight affinity for nitrocellulose are preferable.

9. Proportion of resin.If a small proportion of synthetic resin with respect to nitrocellulose is used the character of the resin may be quite soft. Its effect on the nitrocellulose will be to render the latter more flexible. In other words, it acts also as a softening agent. Nitrocellulose will, however, take up or assimilate only a moderate amount of such a soft material without detriment to its other properties. A high proportion of soft resin has too great a softening effect and harder resins shouldbe employed in this case. As a general rule the hardness of the resin preferably should increase with the proportion employed. In some cases a soft resin may be used for softening purposes, coupled with a. hard resin Films of nitro-cellulose and synthetic as an extending binder in order to secure the desired physical properties. In the present invention I preferably employ the synthetic resin in considerable proportion; for example, in an amount at least equal to the nitrocellulose and in some cases in the ratio of up to two parts of synthetic resin to one part of nitrocellulose or even in higher proportions.

10. Color of the synthetic resin.This depends on the color of the coating material desired. White or colorless synthetic resins should be used for very light colored coatings, while red, brown or black synthetic resins may be used for darker colored coatings.

11. Solubility-As noted, the synthetic resin should be soluble in solvents appropriate for nitrocellulose. For example, acetone, various alcohols, ethyl acetate, amyl acetate and the like and mixtures of these with benzol, etc.

12. Stability of resin on exposure.Preferably the synthetic resin should show good resistance to weathering influences. It appears, however, that the synthetic resin and nitrocellulose may supplement each other so that when mixed the durability of the resulting coating is greater than that of either employed singly. For inside application, for example, on furniture the coating may, of course, be less durable.

13. Livering.The synthetic resin should not possess an acid nature when used with basic pigments such as zinc oxide or white lead and react with these pigments to cause objectionable thickening so that the coating becomes difficult to pp y.

14. Nitrocellulose-The toughness and elasticity of nitrocellulose are desired in the coating in a preeminent way, therefore the maximum amount of nitrocellulose which can be incorporated without making a solution so viscous that it cannot be readily applied should be an objective. A low-viscosity nitrocellulose preferably is used in order to secure the maximum proportion of this substance consistent with ease of application. Nitrocelluloses such as gun cotton and the like forming highly viscous solutions therefore are not as desirable. Ordinary nitrocellulose of the type known as soluble cotton may be used. Cotton which has been exposed to heat at a temperature above C. and having thereby a greatly diminished viscosity especially is useful. The cheapest stock for making the coating probably is celluloid scrap. Moving picture film or other white scrap may be used for light coatings, and tortoise shell comb cuttings and dust and the like used for darker colors. Celluloid scrap may be rendered low in viscosity by heating to -130 C. in a solution of calcium chloride for an hour or two; or by dry heating at between 100 and G. Since the use of low-viscosity nitrocellulose or celluloid forms a feature of the preferred embodiment of the present invention, further details will be hereinafter given.

15. Stabilizers.--Urea and its derivatives, amines, magnesium lactate and the like may be used as stabilizers. Zinc oxide, whiting and other basic pigments act as stabilizers. Celluloid ordinarily contains a stabilizer.

16. Dehydration-Soluble cotton containing 5 per cent or so of water may be dried before use. A bone-dry product reduces the amount of relatively costly water-eliminants.

17. .S'ofteners.The purpose of using softeners is to prevent brittleness. A variety of substances may be employed which are compatible with nitrocellulose and the synthetic resins employed.

Softeners include castor oil, nitrated castor oil, certain boiled and blown oils such, for example,

as blown rape oil, camphor, camphor acetate, diethyl phthalate, acetanilide, triacetin, triphenyl and tricresyl phosphates. For best results the softener-should be entirely compatible both with the nitrocellulose and the synthetic resin.

18. Natural resins-The addition of natural resins such as dammar or shellac, congo, copal and the like is not precluded. A proportion in excess of the amount of synthetic resin simultaneously employed is not usually desirable. Natural resins are too inflexible in their physical properties to be readily adjustable to meet the conditions of the present invention and their use is preferably confined to the status of moderate additions.

19. Miscellaneous ingredients.0ther substances which may be used to a greater or less degree include cellulose acetate, cellulose ethers and the like. Also fire retardants may be added including various chlorinated solids and appropriate mineral salts. When the coating is to be used on wooden surfaces the infiammability preferably is reduced to the lowest point practicable.

20. SoZvents.-As stated these are usually composite and a typical one consists of three components,

(a) a highly volatile liquid which is a good solvent for nitrocellulose;

(b) a slowly volatile solvent which is a good solvent for nitrocellulose and which serves as a water-eliminant;

(c) a volatile non-solvent employed as a cheapening agent.

Under group a) are included such solvents as acetone, methyl acetone, methyl ethyl ketone,

methyl and ethyl acetate, various ethers and ethyl formate. Methyl and ethyl alcohol are not as good solvents and are best used with one or more .of the foregoing active solvents.

Under group (b) butyl and amyl alcohol, amyl acetate, diacetone alcohol, ethyl carbonate and the like are included as high boiling solvents or water eliminants. Furfural may be used to advantage. Furfural is a very active solvent for most forms of nitrocellulose, but is especially useful in preparing solutions made from low-viscosity nitrocellulose, particularly those products which have been reduced in viscosity by special heat treatment. Furfural is usually dark in color and it is resinified by acids. Therefore in using furfural some mildly basic material advantageously may be present to stabilize the solution and prevent the formation of acids which would affect the furfural. Also it is best to employ i'urfural only in the preparation of darker colored 1 coatings.

- (c) solvents usually are substantially free from water. They are valuable either because they act as resin solvents or because when admixed with alcohol or acetone they afford a solvent mixture which dissolves many synthetic resin very freely.

Sometimes solvents of the group (c) type are omitted entirely for various reasons, such as modification of viscosity or increase in the quantity of synthetic resin, etc.

21. Anhydrous conditions-The presence of water in small amountscauses blushing on drying and unless a water-eliminant is present a white film lacking in strength results. It is very de- Dry nitrocellulose and anhydrous solvents of a highly volatile character reduce the amount of or render unnecessary the use of the more costly high boiling solvents. In any event, a lesser amount of the latter is generally required in the winter season when the air is dry. In a humid climate the amount of high boiling solvents may be increased to correspond to the conditions.

22. VarnisIies.-Lacquers made from nitrocellulose usually have a high proportion of solvents.

varnishes made in accordance with the present invention are preferably produced with the aid of heat treated low-viscosity nitrocellulose in conjunction with a fairly high proportion of synthetic resins in order to raise the total solids to as high a degree as possible. Preferably the total solids should be from 30 to per cent. The addition of dyes soluble in the solvents employed, but preferably water-insoluble, serves to make varnish stains.

. 23. Use of a priming coat.1n Serial 684,358 I have proposed, among other primers, that an oil primer may be used and I shall first refer to a primer of this type. Such a primer, as noted in the aforesaid application, may be employed on metal to assist in adhesion. Nitrocellulose. coatings of themselves, as previously indicated, have low adhesive properties. An oil primer or a primer of a character substantially dissimilar to that of the outer coatings, such as one of the synthetic resin priming coatings later mentioned, preferably is used.

It may be noted that the surface, if of steel or other metal, first may be cleaned by sand-blasting or treatment with some solvent or cleaning liquid, e. g., a solution of phosphoric acid in alcohol. The surface may be scoured with steel wool and washed with hot water.

In an illustration given in Serial 684,358 there may be applied to the surface, after the latter has been cleaned, a red oxide primer or other suitable oil-primer and-the priming coat exposed to a temperature of 150 C. for 1 to 2 hours to cause rapid and thorough drying. This baking step also forms a part of the invention of the present application. The automobile body, or whatever metallic surface is being treated, may be putty glazed and coated with a sand surfacer. The latter likewise may be baked at about 150 C. for an hour or more. These coatings serve to form a good under-finish or foundation which can be rubbed to a smooth surface by sand papering. After sanding the surface is washed with water.

When applying the coating to wooden surfaces Said Serial 684,358 likewise has pointed out that coatings.

a synthetic resin priming coat may be employed. Such a synthetic resin as has been described in the foregoing may be used to advantage in such priming coat, forming as stated in the preceding a coating preferably of a character substantially dissimilar to that of the outer coatings.

24. Applying nitrocellulose-synthetic resin coating. -The surface having been primed with a baked priming coat as aforesaid is now in readiness to receive the nitrocellulose synthetic resin These may be applied with brush or air-gun. After applying a coating the latter may be exposed to a temperature of 50 C. for half an hour. A second coat is applied and similarly dried. The finish then is rubbed with boiled linseed oil and rottenstone and if desired may be given a wax finish or polish (carnauba or candelilla wax). If two coats are not adequate, an additional number may be applied.

The following example is one taken from Serial 684,358 to illustrate compositions adapted for use in connection with the production of the surface finish of the present invention.

Example 1 Low-viscosity nitrocellulose--- 5 parts by weight Phthalic glyceride rosin ester 5 parts Blown rape oil 7 parts Prussian blue 1 parts (and upwards) Composite solvent 60 parts The low-viscosity nitrocellulose referred to in the foregoing formula has been heat-treated to render its viscosity as low as possible and its solubility high. The composite solvent is made from 7 parts denatured alcohol, 28 parts ethyl acetate, parts butyl alcohol, 20 parts amyl acetate. It will be noted that this solvent does not contain any benzol. The synthetic resin is made as follows: 35 parts by weight of glycerine, 134 parts of common rosin, and 31 parts of phthalic anhydride are mixed and heated under a reflux condenser until a temperature of 270 C. is reached. 'Ihecondenser is of such length that the water formed by the reaction escapes while glycerine is retained.

Example 2 Moving picture film is boiled in water, preferably somewhat alkaline to remove the emulsion and the stripped material is heated to 160 C. for 2 to 5 seconds. This heat-treatment effects a remarkable reduction in viscosity which expressed in a comparative way is indicated by the fact -that a solution of the untreated celluloid film had a viscosity represented by 24 minutes while a solution made from the-heat-treated product exhibited a viscosity of about 45 seconds.

2.7 parts by weight of phthalic anhydride and 1 part of glycerine were heated together to a temperature of about 230 C. When the temperature reached this point theheating was discontinued, as further heating is liable to bring resin.

about the formation of an insoluble product. A soluble resin was obtained which was incorporated with the heat-treated celluloid film ob tained 'as above.

Proportions used were 2 parts by weight of the heat-treated film to 4.8 parts phthalic glyceride These components were dissolved in 8 parts of a composite solvent made up of 2 parts furfural, 1 part ethyl acetate, 3 parts acetone and 2 parts benzol. On drying a brownish film was obtained which showed no segregation, under the microscope, and which was hard and tough. To the foregoing various softeners such for example as those previously described and the requisite quantity of a suitable pigment may be added. The pigment should be ground in the solvent solution or in a mixture to secure the best spreading qualities.

The various methods of producing nitrocellulose of low-viscosity by heattreatment have been set forth in my patent application, Serial No. 682,553, filed Dec. 24, 1923, now Patent No. 1,816,146, July 28, 1931. The disaggregation or depolymerization of nitrocellulose by such heat treatment to produce low-viscosity material is of special value in connection with the use of furfural as a solvent. It may be noted that commercialfurfural may contain water which will separateand cause turbidity on the addition of benzol. This may be cleared by the addition of acetone or alcohol. Commercial furfural after standing for some time will on drying usually leave a brownish resinous substance of considerable hardness. This substance has a greater tendency to form on baking so that a cementing actionis effected by the used furfural, which perhaps may be compared in some respects with the oxidation of turpentinein ordinary paint. Furfural is used in a composite solvent for lowviscosity nitrocellulose in the proportion of preferably 10 to 30 percent of the total solvents, the balance being highly volatile solvents, such as acetone, ethyl acetate, alcohol, benzol and the like. 1

Furthermore, it may be noted that the addition of benzol to low-viscosity solutions tends to increase the viscosity somewhat and when the lowest degree of Viscosity is required benzol and similar nonesolvent preferablyshould be avoided and acetone, ethyl acetate and the like used instead.

Example 3 30 parts by weight of toluidine and a like amount of tung oil are heated with 6 parts of zinc chloride dissolved in 5 parts of water. The

heating is carried out in a flask open or arranged with an ordinary condenser to carry off vapors without refluxing action, temperature being raised to 285 C., producing a reddish resin. Equal parts of this resin and low-viscosity soluble cotton were dissolved in acetone to produce a solution of 20 per cent strength and upwards. The solutions were low in viscosity and on drying formed yellow to brown films which were very flexible. The toluidine-tung oil resin has a very useful softening action as well as furnishing a .resinous extending constituent. The films were bright and clear with a good gloss and without any indications of segregation when subjected to microscopic examination.

To compositions of this character a dye of an appropriate shade may be added to produce a varnish stain, or a finely ground pigment may be introduced. Thus onemay prepare stains or paints of, for example, a mahogany color intend ed for coating the steel interiors of railway coaches to yield an imitation of mahogany wood.

In priming a surface finish-with theaid of a,

synthetic resin such as the foregoing, a thorough baking, as has'been emphasized in Serial 684,358, is. desirable. A coated metal product within the purview of the present invention thus is obtained.

Example 4 1 part of nitrocellulose film, rendered low in viscosity by heating a few minutes to 160 C; as described in the foregoing, .2 parts of resin made from toluidine and tung oil as described above, 2 to 3 parts of acetone and 1201 part of furfural, the proportions being by weight, yields a heavy-bodiedliquid from which a varnish, paint or stain can be .made in accordance with the foregoing. y

Example 5 Equal parts of furfural and aniline are heated for 1 hour at200 C. yielding a dark brown to black may be utilized ina similar manner.

resin. 4.8 parts by weight of this resin and 2 parts of celluloid film, rendered low in viscosity by heating at 160 C. as described above, were incorporated with a mixed solvent composed of 2 parts by weight of furfural to 1 part of ethyl acetate, 3 parts of acetone and 2 parts of benzol.

This yielded a composition which although liquid was too heavy-to be applied by brushing or spraying and required the addition of a thinner to yield a consistency adapted for addition-of pigments and the like. The films obtained or coatings produced were very dark in. color, hence the composition is adapted. only for producing coatings in the darker shades.

Resins described in some detail in Serial 22,882 These resins, as set forth in the first paragraph of the specification of Serial 22,882, comprise the resinous reaction products of glycerol, phthalic anhydride or other analogous aromatic or aliphatic organic acid and a hydroxylated aliphatic acid,

preferably ricinoleic acid; such resinous composi-- tion in the preferred embodiment being incorporated with nitrocellulose; all preferably dissolved in a mutual solvent. which are flexible and adhere well tometallic surfaces. Lack of adhesion is a, difficulty frequently encountered in nitrocellulose coatings employed as lacquer enamels.-

The examples which follow 22,882 and to distinguish from those set forth above derived from Serial 684,358 the following series will be numbered 1a, 1b, etc.

Example 1a Glycerol 47 parts by weight, phthalic anhydride parts and crude ricinoleic acid 30 parts. The latter was prepared by completely saponifyin'g castor oil with an alkali and thenacidulating and washing. The reaction was carried out in a ves-' sel equipped with a reflux condenser and provided with an agitator. Heat was applied gradually, the temperature being raised to 260 C.; the entire time of the reaction being approximately one hour. A light colored hardand rather tough resin was obtained, the yield being 152 parts.

. Example 11: If glycerol and phthalic anhydride in like proportions are heated to 230 C. and the ricinoleic acid then added in proportions as given above, onheating to about 270 C. polymerization sets in with the formation of resins insoluble in These afford films are from Serial organic solvents. It is preferable, therefore, to carry out the reaction of the three ingredients simultaneously or to add the ricinoleic acid at such a stage in the reaction that polymerization does'not occur. It may be noted that the ricinoleic acids have a desirable effect on raising the temperature at which polymerization occurs. With glycerol and phthalic-anhydride alone insoluble material is likely to be formed at about 230 C.,while in the presence of the ricinoleic acid Phthalic ricinoleic glyceride resin 9.6 parts by weight, low viscosity nitrocellulose 4.8 parts, butyl acetate 24 parts, butyl alcohol 9.6 parts,

toluol 24 parts. a

In this composition the ratio of resin to nitrocellulose is 2:1. The color of the solution is light and the coating dries readily on, for example, a

well-cleaned sheet of metal affording a good lacquer coating'having excellentadhesion. On baking for half an hour at C. the film did not become brittle. The surface was glossy and there was no exudation of greasy material. Owing to the toughening and plasticizing effect of phthalic ricinoleic glyceride resin on nitrocellulose no softening agentsuch as is usually required had to be added, as the film was notably flexible.

To recapitulate: that part of the foregoing disclosure which appertains more specifically to the present invention embraces as a surface finish a baked coating, preferably solution-deposited, containing a synthetic resinpreferably oneof the polybasic acid-polyhydric alcohol type, including the phthalic glyceride resins and their modified forms, such as higher fatty acid phthalic glycerideresins; such baked coating being adapted to receive and compatibly carry, a coating comprising nitrocellulose, specifically low-viscosity nitrocellulose, and said baked coating preferably carrying another finish coating in contact therewith, or

' other superposed or juxtaposed finish coatings as desired, there being present preferably low-viscosity nitrocellulose in at least one of the coatings of the finish and the undercoat or undercoats containing said synthetic resin as an essential component, preferably being baked into adherent contact with a support such as metal, including the bodies of automobiles and the like, the temperatures in baking preferably being within the range 100 to C.

' What I claim is:

1. An article of manufacture having a surface finish comprising an adherent baked coating containing a'synthetic resin of the polybasicacid-polyhydric-alcohol-type and a dissimilar finish coating in contact therewith.

'2. 'An article of manufacture having a surface finish of the character specified in claim 1 in .which low-viscosity nitrocellulose is present in at least one of the coatings of said finish.

3. A surface finish, coating a metallic support, said finish comprising an adherent baked coating containing a synthetic resin of the polybasic acidpolyhydric alcohol type and another finish coating in contact therewith, at least one of the coatings including low viscosity nitrocellulose.

4. An article of manufacture having a surface finish comprising an adherent baked coating containing a synthetic resin and a superposed finish coating differing from the base coating in contact therewith.

5. The combination of a metal article, a coating thereon comprising an alkyd resin, and a superimposed opaque coating comprising a cellulose compound.

6. The method of coating metal surfaces with cellulose lacquer which consists in applying a priming coat of alkyd resin, applying a lacquer comprising a cellulose ester and a solvent capable of entering into the alkyd resin and finally air drying.

7. The combination of a metal article, a coating thereon comprising a lycerol-phthalic anhydride resin and a superimposed coating of cellulose derivative composition.

8. An article of manufacture carrying a primer coating of a hardened polyhydric-alcohol polybasic-acid resin and a superimposed coating containing a cellulose compound.

9. An article of manufacture carrying a primer coating of a hardened polyhydric-alcohol polybasic-acid resin and a superimposed coating containing a cellulose compound and a synthetic resin compatible with the cellulose compound.

10. An article of manufacture carrying a. primer coating of a hardened polyhydric-alcohol polybasic-acid monobasic-acid resin and a superimposed coating containing a cellulose compound.

' plying a dissimilar coating thereover.

pound. 6

12. An article of manufacture carrying a primer coating of a hardened polyhydric-alcohol polybasic-acid resin and over the primer coating a coating of a composition differing from said primer coating.

13. The method of coating articles of manufacture which consists in applying thereto a priming coat of a soluble polyhydric-alcohol polybasicacid resin, hardening said priming coat, and ap- 14. The method of coating articles of manufacture which consists in applying thereto a priming coat of a soluble polyhydric-alcohol polybasic-acid resin, hardening said priming coat, and applying a nitrocellulose lacquer coating there- 2 over. i

15. An article of manufacture carrying a primer coating of a polyhydric alcohol-polybasic acid resin, and a superimposed coating containing a cellulose compound. 2

16. An article of manufacture carrying a tightly adhering coating comprising a mixed ester of glycerin having as the acid components, phthalic acid and a higher fatty acid, and a dissimilar superposed topcoat on the tightly adhering coating.

17. An article of manufacture carrying a tightly adhering coating comprising a mixed ester of a polyhydric alcohol having as the acid components a polybasic acid and a higher fatty acid, 3 and a topcoat thereon comprising a cellulose compound.

' CARLETON ELLIS. 

